In a notable victory for G.D. Pharmaceuticals Private Limited (the plaintiff), the Hon’ble Delhi High Court has recently bestowed the prestigious designation of “well-known” mark upon their trademark ‘BOROLINE’. This declaration marks a significant milestone in a legal battle that has spanned several years, reflecting both the enduring legacy and the impressive reputation of the ‘BOROLINE’ brand.
Case Overview
The legal dispute began in 2019 when G.D. Pharmaceuticals filed a suit seeking a permanent injunction against a competitor using a deceptively similar mark. The defendant, trading under the mark ‘BOROBEAUTY’, not only mimicked the name but also the trade dress of the plaintiff’s products. The similarity in branding, including the color scheme and product arrangement, led to accusations of trademark infringement, copyright violations, passing off, and unfair competition.
In response to the plaintiff’s suit, the defendant agreed to amend their trade dress and rename their products. Consequently, the court ruled in favor of G.D. Pharmaceuticals, imposing costs on the defendant and granting the requested relief.
Evidence Supporting the “Well-Known” Mark Status
As the litigation neared its conclusion, G.D. Pharmaceuticals sought to elevate their trademark ‘BOROLINE’ to the status of a “well-known” mark. This status, though not explicitly requested at the suit’s inception, was granted by the court based on several compelling factors:
- Historical Use: The plaintiff demonstrated that ‘BOROLINE’ had been coined and adopted in 1929, maintaining continuous use since then.
- Registration Portfolio: Evidence was provided showing 21 trademark registrations in India, with the first registration dating back to 1949. The plaintiff also showcased international registrations in Oman, Turkey, UAE, and Bangladesh.
- Brand Recognition: The brand’s prominence was underscored by its selection as an Indian “Consumer Super Brand” six times between 2003 and 2017 and as a “Master Brand” in 2014. It was also featured as one of the “Most Desirable 30 Power Brands” in 2018.
- Consumer Loyalty and Goodwill: G.D. Pharmaceuticals highlighted the extensive consumer base and the significant goodwill the brand has garnered over three generations of loyal customers, including doctors, chemists, and patients.
- Sales and Promotion: Detailed records of sales figures and promotional expenditures over 12 years were submitted, further establishing the brand’s extensive market presence.
- Historical Significance: A noteworthy piece of evidence included an advertisement for ‘BOROLINE’ published on August 15, 1947—India’s Independence Day—emphasizing the brand’s long-standing presence in the Indian market.
Judgement and Implications
The Hon’ble Delhi High Court’s ruling declared ‘BOROLINE’ a “well-known” mark, acknowledging its status as a household name and one of the oldest trademarks in continuous use in India. This decision is not just a win for G.D. Pharmaceuticals but also serves as a landmark in understanding what constitutes a “well-known” mark under the Indian Trade Mark Act, 1999.
Conclusion
This case highlights the type of evidence required to secure the “well-known” mark status in India. It demonstrates the importance of a long history of use, extensive market presence, and significant consumer recognition in achieving this distinguished status. For companies with longstanding and reputable trademarks, this ruling reaffirms the legal protections available and sets a benchmark for future cases involving well-known marks.
For more insights into trademark law and related legal victories, stay tuned to our blog.
